GED Reasoning Through Language ArtsExtended Response (Essay)Medium
A student is writing an argumentative essay about the role of technology in modern education. They have found two sources: Source A, an article from an educational technology journal discussing the benefits of AI tutors, and Source B, an opinion piece from a parent's blog expressing concerns about screen time. To present a balanced and persuasive argument, the student should primarily:
- AFocus exclusively on Source A to highlight the benefits, as it's from an academic journal.
- BSummarize both sources side-by-side without integrating their perspectives into a unified argument.
- CDiscredit Source B due to its informal nature and focus only on peer-reviewed content.
- DUse Source A to present the advantages and Source B to address potential drawbacks, offering a comprehensive view.
Show answer & explanationAnswer & explanation
Correct answer: D. Use Source A to present the advantages and Source B to address potential drawbacks, offering a comprehensive view.
A balanced and persuasive argument acknowledges both the positive and negative aspects of an issue. Using Source A for benefits and Source B for drawbacks demonstrates a comprehensive understanding and addresses counterarguments, strengthening the overall persuasion.
Why the other options are wrong
- A. Focusing exclusively on one side ignores the complexity of the issue and weakens the argument's balance.
- B. Summarizing without integration fails to build a cohesive argument; the goal is to use sources to support a point, not just present them.
- C. Dismissing a source, even if informal, without engaging with its content limits the argument's scope and ability to address diverse perspectives.
Balanced Argument
An argument that acknowledges and addresses multiple perspectives, including potential counterarguments or drawbacks, to present a more comprehensive and credible position.
- Strengthens credibility by showing a thorough understanding.
- Often involves acknowledging opposing views before refuting or qualifying them.
- Avoids presenting an overly simplistic or one-sided view.
Memory trick: Balance Brings Better Beliefs.