GED Reasoning Through Language ArtsReading ComprehensionMedium
A student is analyzing an online forum discussion about a controversial new city ordinance restricting public gatherings. One commenter writes: 'This new rule is an egregious overreach by the council! They're stripping away our basic rights, turning our city into a police state. We must resist this tyranny before it's too late!' Which of the following best describes the commenter's point of view?
- AAlarmist and oppositional
- BCurious and questioning
- CSupportive and collaborative
- DNeutral and objective
Show answer & explanationAnswer & explanation
Correct answer: A. Alarmist and oppositional
The commenter uses strong, negative language ('egregious overreach,' 'stripping away our basic rights,' 'police state,' 'tyranny,' 'must resist') to express extreme disapproval and a sense of impending disaster. This highly emotional and exaggerated language indicates an alarmist perspective, and their call to 'resist' confirms an oppositional stance.
Why the other options are wrong
- B. The commenter is making definitive statements and calls to action, not asking questions.
- C. The commenter is clearly against the ordinance, not supportive or collaborative.
- D. The language is highly emotional and biased, not neutral or objective.
Point of View: Alarmist/Oppositional
A perspective characterized by the use of exaggerated language, dire predictions, and strong negative emotional appeals to warn of perceived dangers or to actively oppose a particular idea, policy, or action.
- Uses emotionally charged words (e.g., 'tyranny,' 'catastrophe').
- Often forecasts worst-case scenarios.
- Aims to provoke fear or outrage and mobilize opposition.
Memory trick: Alarmist: 'A-larm' bells ringing, warning of danger.