GED Reasoning Through Language ArtsReading ComprehensionHard
A historian is examining two primary source letters from the same period, discussing a significant political event. Letter A, written by a government official, emphasizes the 'unanimous public support' for a new policy. Letter B, written by a local merchant, details 'widespread discontent' and 'growing protests' against the same policy. What is the most significant discrepancy between these two accounts?
- AThe authors' spelling and grammar.
- BThe reported level of public approval for the policy.
- CThe age of the authors.
- DThe geographical location from which the letters were sent.
Show answer & explanationAnswer & explanation
Correct answer: B. The reported level of public approval for the policy.
Letter A claims 'unanimous public support,' while Letter B describes 'widespread discontent' and 'growing protests.' These are direct contradictions regarding the public's reception of the policy, representing the most significant discrepancy in their accounts.
Why the other options are wrong
- A. Spelling and grammar are stylistic, not substantive discrepancies about the event itself.
- C. The letters are from the 'same period,' age is not mentioned as a factor.
- D. While location might influence perspective, the core discrepancy is about the *nature* of public reaction, not just where it was observed.
Inferring Discrepancy
Identifying a significant difference, inconsistency, or contradiction between two or more pieces of information or accounts.
- Requires careful comparison of details from different sources.
- Focus on conflicting facts, interpretations, or perspectives.
- Helps in understanding bias or incomplete information.
Memory trick: V.I.P.S. = Viewpoint, Information, Purpose, Style