GED Reasoning Through Language ArtsReading ComprehensionHard
A student is reading an online forum discussion about a controversial new city ordinance. One commenter writes: 'This ordinance is nothing but a thinly veiled attempt by the city council to control every aspect of our lives. They claim it's for public safety, but it's clearly an infringement on personal liberty.' Which of the following statements best describes the commenter's point of view?
- ASuspicious and critical of the ordinance.
- BSupportive of the city council's intentions.
- CUninformed about the ordinance's details.
- DNeutral and objective regarding the ordinance.
Show answer & explanationAnswer & explanation
Correct answer: A. Suspicious and critical of the ordinance.
Phrases like 'nothing but a thinly veiled attempt,' 'control every aspect of our lives,' and 'clearly an infringement on personal liberty' indicate a strong negative and distrustful stance toward the city council and the ordinance.
Why the other options are wrong
- B. The language clearly expresses strong opposition, not support.
- C. The commenter articulates specific concerns about control and liberty, suggesting they are informed enough to form a strong opinion, even if it's a biased one.
- D. The use of strong, opinionated language ('nothing but,' 'clearly') shows a subjective and critical stance, not neutrality.
Inferring Point of View (Critical)
Deducing an author's or speaker's negative or disapproving stance on a topic based on their word choice, tone, and arguments.
- Look for negative connotations in language.
- Identify words that express disapproval or skepticism.
- Consider what the author is arguing against.
Memory trick: What's the 'view' from the author's 'point' of writing?